A UK tribunal ruled Thursday that the Home Office can't keep secret that it ordered Apple to build access to encrypted data, a demand known as a "technical capability notice." The order itself still stands. The ruling comes from the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, as reported by TechCrunch and 9to5Mac.

What the tribunal allowed

  • The order can be confirmed. The tribunal said the Home Office has "not established that it would be damaging to national security" to reveal the notice, per the Financial Times. Before the ruling, Apple was legally barred from discussing it, even after details leaked.
  • Much of the case can go public. "Much" of the challenge by Apple and non-profit groups can now be heard in open court, and the demand itself can be challenged there. The order stays in place for now.
  • A first. Liberty says it is the first known time the government has been forced to allow confirmation of a secret technical order.

What is still undecided

  • The order's contents. A final hearing on which specific details can be released is expected next year.
  • Official confirmation. The Home Office has yet to confirm the notice exists, and did not respond to a request for comment.

How we got here

In 2025, the government reportedly demanded that Apple build a way for UK authorities to reach customer data anywhere in the world. Details leaked, drawing criticism from White House officials and US lawmakers.

Apple refused and stopped UK users from turning on Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption feature for iCloud. The order was later narrowed to British nationals' data, and Apple challenged that second order too. Apple has said it has "never built a backdoor or master key" to any of its products and "never will."

What this means for you

Advanced Data Protection stays off for UK iPhone users for now. Apple has not said whether it will bring it back.

For related coverage, see Germany's iPhone spyware warning and how to back up an iPhone.

What we checked

We have not read the judgment text. The tribunal's judgments page lists a 19 November 2026 entry for Apple and the Home Secretary, and the quotes come from the reports linked above, including the Financial Times as relayed there. Apple did not respond after the ruling, and we saw no Home Office or Apple statement.